EU fisheries

[oliver]

From the BBC website

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/8067560.stm

The Scottish Fishermen's Federation has said it is delighted with European Union moves to scrap current rules which decide fishing quotas.

A meeting of European fisheries ministers in Brussels concluded with a consensus for a new Common Fisheries Policy to be radically decentralised.

This would give more power to member states and to the fishing industry.

Bertie Armstrong of the SFF said the present framework did not work and needed to be decentralised.

Environmentalists and fishermen alike have long argued the existing system - set annually - has failed the industry.

Fish caught over quota are dumped back in the sea even if dead, and in the UK alone numbers of fishermen have fallen by a third over the decade.

The European Union has until 2012 to draw up a new Common Fisheries Policy.

Mr Armstrong said: "We've proved beyond all reasonable doubt that the present framework - which is tightly-controlled by the Commission - isn't working at all and needs to be decentralised.

"The outcome of this council seems to be that that's been accepted by all. We weren't absolutely sure that the Commission would be ready to let go and decentralise, but certainly that seems to be the theme. And that's highly welcome."

[RavellingTangler]

and just a week later (June 2, 2009) an environmentalist George Monbiot wrote a scathing attack of commercial fisheries in general (but especially of the GBFT fishery in the Mediterranean, and of scallop-dredging) in a U.K. newspaper (guardian.co.uk)
And of the way politicians seem to cave in so much, so often, to short-term fishing wishes (e.g. raising quotas above suggested levels).



http://www.monbiot.com/archives/2009/06/02/blue-desert/


He's taken his argument (as 'one does') to extremes, but much of what he says is based on fact more than opinion. I'm very tempted to send it to the (U.K.) "Fishing News" with a note suggesting they repeat it verbatim and challenge each criticism that they can, point by point.
or
that they use the Guardian's "response" column to counter.